• Subscribe
QP Briefing
Subscribe
News

The Ontario Liberals arbitration hearing on Scarborough Southwest is set to May 20: A document is pushing back on Erskine-Smith allegations

An internal analysis of "notice of appeal validity" obtained by QP Briefing and dated May 12, pushes back forcefully against those allegations, arguing the appeal “does not establish grounds to overturn the result.”

Published May 14, 2026 at 7:42pm

Barbara Patrocinio
By
Barbara Patrocinio
The Ontario Liberals arbitration hearing on Scarborough Southwest is set to May 20: A document is pushing back on Erskine-Smith allegations

Caucus 20251126 Liberal MP for Beaches-East York Nate Erskine-Smith speaks with reporters as he makes his way to caucus on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Wednesday, Nov. 26, 2025. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld

The Ontario Liberals have scheduled an arbitration hearing for May 20 at 6 p.m. to review an appeal filed by Nate Erskine-Smith over the party’s controversial Scarborough Southwest nomination contest, as the campaign of winning candidate Ahsanul Hafiz prepares an extensive defence arguing the result should stand.

The hearing comes after Erskine-Smith, the federal Liberal MP who lost the May 9 nomination by 19 votes, publicly questioned the integrity of the process and alleged significant irregularities during voting.

An analysis of the allegations called "notice of appeal validity" obtained by QP Briefing and dated May 12, pushes back forcefully against those allegations, arguing the appeal “does not establish grounds to overturn the result.”

Read this for free.

Log in below to get access to this article. One free per week.

About QP Briefing

Queen's Park Briefing is a membership-based information source, covering all political and legislative movements at the provincial level. QP Briefing memberships are held by stakeholders, professionals, business leaders, and Ontario parliamentarians.

Our team provides deep analytic content for a wide array of high level decision makers standing at the intersection of private and public sector affairs. QP Briefing's in-depth coverage keeps our members at the forefront of complex policy issues, political advancements and private sector affairs.

QP Briefing is an invaluable information tool and is a passionate resource for members of the Ontario Public Service, Public Affairs Firms and Strategists, Government Agencies, MP's and all those claiming a stake in provincial politics.

Contact us

Subscriptions and Account Management
sales@ipolitics.ca
Partnerships and Events
Brian Storseth
Publisher
Editorial Inquiries
QP Briefing © 2026. An iPolitics publication.